Overall I would stay again, but I think it would be better in the summer.
Positives:
Great location for exploring south Bruny Island, and handy to the local hotel for meals (we didn't use the cooking facilities).
The washing machine was handy, and the shower and hot water was good.
Not so positive:
The property was a bit cold, even though we used the air conditioner before lighting the wood fire. Once the fire got going the heating was better, however the firebox was full of ashes from previous guests, I had to keep collecting wood from outside (which was wet), and there were only 6 matches for a 3 night stay.
The area under the couch cushions hadn't been cleaned in a long while.
The potholes in the driveway in front of the gate could also do with some maintenance.