Did we enjoy our stay? Yes
Would we like to stay there again? Yes
But the cabin may not be for everyone. Others have commented on deferred maintenance, and you may find window-coverings/windows/window locks that don't work well or at all, flaking paint on the bathroom ceiling, duct tape on the floor, or shaky railings outside. But overall, the place was clean, bright and comfortable; and it has an outstanding view on the beach in a very quiet location. It is nearby many amenities including excellent casual restaurants (with local whitefish). For us, the deficiencies became less and less notable as our stay continued.
The cabin is not necessarily easy to find. It is on Shenandoah ROW (not "Ave" or "Road"), a small dirt road in a private cluster of cabins just west of the Brimley State Park. Our GPS could find it, but Google misidentifies the location.