Overall, the property served us well while there for a long weekend. The owners/ mgmt company were kind and very responsive. Although the Property is quite old, it accommodates 8 people just fine.
Some things things that were not so great (reason for the 4 stars):
Lights did not work below the house, so we had to use flash lights to use the BBQ (very rusty, we used cooking sheets instead of grill area).
Cost for linens and towels is very high and we paid extra to get the linens put on, yet, beds were not made (that was a bummer because we arrived late).
There were basically no supplies (in fairness, they advised of that), but it is inconvenient to have to bring basically everything from soap for 3 bathrooms, toilet paper, dish detergent, laundry detergent, paper towels, hand towels etc.
When I booked the place, I thought we would be able to walk directly to the beach, but there is actually a road and then big huge rocks one had to climb (better be a good climber) to get down to the water and there really isn’t a beach, but we played in the water there, which was nice.
The real bummer was the neighbor though, who called the police on us for being noisy while we were BBQ’ing at 9 pm on a Friday night. Note, we were 4 adults with small kids and were neither loud nor rowdy. The police came and shook their head at the neighbors and left. But it gets better, the following day, the neighbors started screaming and cursing at my friends (a young couple with a 2 year old) who were staying with us. They didn’t realize that the road was one way (no signs to advise of that BTW); anyway they used every f... word in the book on this young family and obviously that was very scary and humiliating... we informed the owner and they advised that they would take this up with the neighbors to ensure future visitors will not have to experience this.
Again, I would like to re-emphasize the responsiveness of the owners/ mgmt company who asked to talk to the police when I called them after the police arrived. They also picked up the phone immediately when we were unable to unlock the lockbox to return the keys prior to departure.